Best Criminal Defense Attorneys in Buffalo, New York

If you are facing criminal charges in Buffalo, New York, then, you need to find the best criminal defense attorneys.

In this article, I have compiled a list of some of the best criminal defense attorneys in Buffalo, New York.

In addition, I also discuss what makes them stand out as top-rated criminal defense attorneys.

Top Rated Criminal Defense Attorneys in Buffalo, New York

Buffalo is a city located in the U.S State of New York
Buffalo is a city located in the U.S State of New York

Below is a list of 10 influential criminal defense attorneys who can represent you in courts located in Buffalo City, New York.


1. Michael Charles Cimasi

Attorney Michael Charles Cimasi. Image from
Attorney Michael Charles Cimasi. Image from

Attorney Michael Charles Cimasi has specialized in criminal defense.

Mainly, attorney Cimasi represents clients charged with Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) and other traffic-related offenses such as speeding and unlicensed operation.

In addition, attorney Cimasi represents clients on parole violations.

One can reach attorney Cimasi through his law firm- The Cimasi Law Office.

He offers an initial free consultation which can be conducted through FaceTime, Google Meet, Skype, and Zoom.


2. Kevin Scott Mahoney

Attorney Kevin Scott Mahoney. Image from
Attorney Kevin Scott Mahoney. Image from

Mr. Scott Mahoney is a senior counsel and a member of Tiveron Law’s Family and Criminal Law Departments.

As a seasoned professional, attorney Scott Mahoney has over 26 years of experience representing accused persons.

if you are facing criminal charges due to drug charges, expungement, fraud, gun crimes, internet crimes, sex crimes, theft, and violent crimes, you should consider retaining the services of attorney Scott Mahoney. Additionally, he can also help with criminal appeals.

Mr. Mahoney has a 10.0 rating on AVVO. He also accepts credit cards as a mode of payment. You can reach attorney Mahoney through his phone at 716.636.7600

3. Matthew Borowski

Attorney Matthew Borowski. inage from
Attorney Matthew Borowski. image from

Attorney Matthew Borowski is a criminal law expert who has specialized in federal criminal defense and post-conviction relief.

He operates under “Borowski Law” whose physical offices are located in downtown Buffalo, New York.

He accepts credit cards and charges a flat fee of $300 for consultation

Apart from criminal defense, Mr. Matthew Borowski is also an immigration law expert.

His passion for immigration law stems from the fact that he is a first-generation son of an immigrant. Mr. Borowski regularly features in news media outlets such as CNN, NBC, and ABC.

4. Lisa M. Yaeger

Attorney Lisa M. Yaeger. Image from
Attorney Lisa M. Yaeger. Image from

Attorney Lisa M. Yaeger is a criminal defense attorney located in Buffalo.

She boasts over 30 years of legal experience in the Western New York Court system.

Before venturing to private practice Ms. Yaeger was an Assistant District Attorney (DA) in the Erie County DA’s Office.

Currently, attorney Lisa Yaeger is a senior counsel at the Tiveron Law PLLC.

If you need representation, you can contact her on the phone at 716.636.7600

5. Robert Singer

Attorney Rob Singer. Image from
Attorney Rob Singer. Image from

Attorney Robert Singer is one of the most sought criminal defense attorneys in Buffalo.

He is also the founder of Singer Legal PLLC, which opened its doors in 2018.

Before opening his firm, Mr. Singer was a defense counsel, prosecutor, general counsel, and Special Assistant U.S. Attorney in various roles in the military, the Federal government, and in private practice.

Mr. Singer is also rated as a Super Lawyer.

You can reach Attorney Rob Singer by phone at (716) 222-3288

Attorney Anthony Lana. Image from
Photo of Attorney Timothy Hennessy. Source (

Mr. Timothy Hennessy is a prominent criminal defense attorney in Buffalo.

In 2009, Mr. Hennessy opened Timothy J. Hennessy, PLLC, a law firm that offers responsive and responsible representation to clients in the greater Buffalo, New York area.

Mr. Hennessy has also specialized in matrimonial and family law.

You can reach attorney Timothy Hennessy at 716-276-0980 for a free initial consultation and case evaluation.

7. Michael J. Stachowski

Attorney Stachowski. Image from
Attorney Stachowski. Image from

Michael Stachowski is an experienced attorney with experience navigating through the criminal justice system.

With over 45 years of experience, he employs his knowledge and vast network of resources on behalf and to the benefit of his clients

If you are facing charges regarding Assault and Battery, DWI, Drug and Gun Charges, Homicide, and Sex Crimes, do not hesitate to contact Mr. Stachowski at 716-824-5353 to arrange for an initial consultation.

Mr. Stachowski is also an accomplished appellate law attorney who can help you in the aftermath of a conviction.

8. Louis Mussari

Attorney Louis C. Mussari. Image from
Attorney Louis C. Mussari. Image from

Louis Mussari is a former prosecutor.

His areas of expertise include handling crimes related to drug possession. sex offenses, gun crimes, violent crimes, theft and burglary, Juvenile offenses, DWI/DUI defense, and Fraud and white-collar crimes.

He is also a professor at the University at Buffalo, where he instructs others in criminal defense strategies

You can contact Louis Mussari through his office address 42 Delaware Ave. Suite 770 Buffalo, New York 14202 or via phone at  716-430-2147

9. Samantha Chorny

Attorney Samantha Chorny. Image from
Attorney Samantha Chorny. Image from

Attorney Samatha Chorny is the founder of SMC Law Firm- a law firm of criminal defense attorneys operating in Buffalo.

Ms. Samantha Chorny is a fierce advocate who defends people accused of crimes.

Before opening her law firm, Ms Chorny was a Senior Associate Attorney at Rosenberg Criminal Defense Law Firm. She also previously worked as a prosecutor in the Nassau County DA’s Office.

During her time at the DA’s office, she tried numerous cases to verdict and prosecuted thousands of misdemeanor and felony cases ranging from major assaults to financial crimes to drugs and gun possession cases

You can contact her at (212) 651-4006

10. Anthony J Lana

Attorney Anthony Lana. Image from
Attorney Anthony Lana. Image from

Attorney Anthony J. Lana is a DWI specialist known throughout the greater Buffalo region.

Mr. Lana has established a remarkable criminal law practice with a proven track record of success.

Among his many professional accomplishments, Mr. Lana Mr. Lana made New York State case law while representing his client in People v Garlock. This case is now cited by other attorneys and judges in the area of DWI defense.

You can contact attorney Anthony at 716-510-3527

What to look for in a criminal defense attorney

When one decides to hire a criminal defense attorney, you should consider the following factors:

  • The level of experience of the attorney. An experienced attorney can improve your chances of avoiding jail time.
  • The local networks of the attorney. Attorneys with local networks have a better understanding of the local procedures. Further, there is a high degree of chance that they have first-hand experience with the prosecutors and the judges who are handling your case.
  • Accessibility and availability should also play a huge role when you are searching for a good attorney. A good attorney should always be prompt in their communication and updates regarding the status of your case.
  • Legal fees also influence who you choose as a lawyer. The best attorney will usually charge higher legal fees as compared to their less experienced colleagues
  • Certifications of the attorney. Martindale-Hubbell and Super Lawyers usually rate the best attorneys. Also, while not all attorneys achieve such achievements, some may have received awards from organizations such as the National Trial Lawyers.
  • Ratings can inform you about the good and bad sides of an attorney. Many online directory websites such as AVVO contain information and ratings on a particular lawyer. On such sites, you might find the profile of a lawyer and a review of their expertise from their clients.


This article is meant to introduce you to some of the best criminal defense attorneys in Buffalo.

I have compiled the list from sources such as Justia, FindLaw, Super Lawyers, and AVVO.

If you want to find more criminal defense attorneys, you can always look for more attorneys from the above-mentioned online sources.

Additionally, you can seek referrals from your friends or relatives.

In any case, you should consider the criteria that I have discussed above when deciding to hire the best attorney to help you defend your criminal charge.

I hope this article has been helpful.